Score: 7

"The slow scrolling text is REALLY annoying"

submission: Epic Battle Fantasy 2

date: 4 hours ago

There's a skip button there, but why can't I just read through the story at my own pace?

Score: 6

"Good game"

submission: Pandemic Boy

date: December 21, 2009

The infection counter is broken.. it often will say something like 94/80 people infected.

Score: 3

"Doesn't work very well"

submission: Unlock The Box

date: December 15, 2009

Several times I tried to move a piece and couldn't move it, so I gave up and tried something else. Later I found that the original piece I'd wanted to move was movable in the first place, which is just infuriating. In particular: the top and right sides of the first puzzle and the spinners in the third only work every once in a while. Fix this and maybe you've got a game here.

Score: 1

"Not much gameplay"

submission: Metal Monster

date: December 11, 2009

I didn't seem to have much control over the game strategically.

Score: 2

"Don't get it"

submission: Kiss in the Rain

date: December 8, 2009

I've seen a few games like this recently... where does the "make sure nobody looks at you while you're kissing" game mechanic come from? Doesn't make sense to me.

Score: 0

"needs work"

submission: Xerb 3

date: December 8, 2009

The graphics are confusing, the font unreadable, the scores don't all show up at the end, and the idea has been done to death with much slicker implementation. Try again.

Score: 8

"Original concept!"

submission: Halfsies

date: December 7, 2009

Maybe have the shapes color-cycle in time with the music to make the game draw the player in a little more.

Score: 0

"Not too simple, just not any fun."

submission: A Real Simple Flash Game2

date: December 7, 2009

Seriously, people, consider whether a game is enjoyable before you ever start making it. Clearly you're just submitting this because you think it's awesome that you figured out how to write ten lines of actionscript.

Score: 2

"Is there actually a bottom?"

submission: Cave Fall

date: December 3, 2009

I played for several minutes until I decided that it might just be an infinite loop, so I stopped.

Score: 0

"what?"

submission: Black Forest

date: November 24, 2009

Okay, so now I know how to make a chocolate cake given that I already have a premade chocolate cake and a penguin that can make a cake...